SF/F Review: The Tangled Lands by Paolo Bacigalupi & Tobias S. Buckell https://t.co/DCxNe9lYsG Short Review: 6 out of 10 (1/3)— garik16 (@garik16) March 29, 2018
Short Review (cont): A quartet of Novellas (2 old, 2 new) set in a world where magic-use is easy but has costs that burden all of society to the point of destroying it, The Tangled Lands just doesn't seem to use this interesting world in ways that stand out, alas. (2/3)— garik16 (@garik16) March 29, 2018
The Tangled Lands is an interesting work to review mainly because it's not clear how to describe it. It's essentially a collection of four novellas - two old, two new - in a shared world, with each novella set after the other. Does that really make it an anthology as I've titled this post? I'm not particularly sure. The two authors created this shared world for an audiobook containing the first two novellas back in 2010, and this compilation adds two more novellas (one from each author) to create a short book.
That said, the problem with this compilation is that, while the shared world is interesting - basically it's a fantasy world where magic is/was commonplace, but casting even the smallest spells results in the creation somewhere in the world of "bramble", which can put people into an everlasting sleep - there isn't enough substance in the novellas to really make them that memorable. The original two novellas are definitely the strongest, but even they aren't particularly unique. The final two novellas are more miss than hit, with them feeling very more of the same. I'd like to see something more in this world (maybe a full length novel?), but this isn't a collection that justifies its existence very much.