Full Disclosure: This book was read as an e-ARC (Advance Reader Copy) obtained via Netgalley from the publisher in advance of the book's release on August 11, 2020 in exchange for a potential review. I give my word that this did not affect my review in any way - if I felt conflicted in any way, I would simply have declined to review the book.
Cry of Metal and Bone is the third novel in L Penelope's Earthsinger Chronicles. The series was initially self published before being picked up by a publisher - and now before this book consists of two novels - Song of Blood and Stone (Reviewed
Here) and Whispers of Shadow and Flame (Reviewed
Here) - and two novellas which serve as prequels/sequels to the novels. The Series is essentially romantic fantasy, with the first one being close to a pure fantasy romance at times* and the second one still featuring romance as a major part of the plot. Perhaps more interesting, the novels feature countries with racial/nationalistic views that will feel very familiar to modern American readers and form important parts of the plots.
*
I use "Fantasy Romance" to describe books in which the primary plot in the book - in its fantasy world - is the romance, which ends on a happy ending whereas "Romantic Fantasy" refers to Fantasy novels where Romance is a central element of the plot but is not the only central focus....and the plot doesn't necessarily end in a happy ending. So for example a book in which our heroes' final goal is to save the world is likely a romantic fantasy whereas one where the ending centers around the finding happiness and love, even if the threat to the world is still out there, is a Fantasy Romance.
I had mixed feelings about the first two books. The first novel (Song of Blood and Stone) had a lovely romance and predictable but well executed fantasy plot, but I felt the socio-political themes seemed a bit too underdone, as was the world in general really, existing mainly as a skeleton for the rest of the plot. The second novel (Whispers of Shadow and Flame) fixed this completely - with the novel taking place at the same time as the first novel in a different setting - and made a far more real feeling, albeit just as familiar and depressing in many ways, world....but felt incomplete at the end with an unsatisfying cliffhanger. Still I really liked the main duo of the second novel and was really interested on seeing where the plot would go forward from its cliffhanger ending, so I quickly requested this third novel on NetGalley when it showed up.
And Cry of Metal and Bone is very good and surprised me greatly and is a much satisfying if still a little frustrating novel compared to its predecessors. The story has fully moved into Epic Fantasy here, with a cast of important characters far more expansive than we started with, and a number of competing subplots all over multiple continents and countries that we flip around between as the plot goes on, and it can't quit manage to cover all of these elements in its duration. And yet, the characters remain excellent, the new and old romances are terrific, and the story & setting continues to hit a number of very important themes - racism and nationalism, the plights of refugees, misogyny and sexism, the corruption of power, etc. - in ways that feel really well done and very real given today's world. I'm not sure how long this series is intended to be - it does not end here - but I'll be back for sure with book 4 after this one, and I'm glad I stuck around.
Note: Minor Spoilers for Books 1 and 2 are inevitable below: