Full Disclosure: This book was read as an e-ARC (Advance Reader Copy) obtained via Netgalley from the publisher in exchange for a potential review as a Hugo voter. I give my word that this did not affect my review in any way - if I felt conflicted in any way, I would simply have declined to review the book.
The Raven Scholar is an epic fantasy - and I mean epic, the book is listed as 700 pages long - and the first of a new fantasy trilogy. The novel has been incredibly well regarded by other authors I follow on social media and is now a Hugo Nominee for Best Novel, so it's been incredibly intriguing to me for a while despite my struggles to get back into reading. The story features a world with eight animal gods - Fox, Raven, Ox, Monkey, Dragon, Hound, Bear, and Tiger - whose existence is questioned but whose return is feared to bring absolute destruction. And then it follows largely a scholar of common birth who is drawn into the Kingdom's competition for succession and a murder mystery and is forced to unravel the mysteries and conspiracies around her before the competition gets herself killed.
The result is a story that uses some interesting and unusual tricks of narration and viewpoint changing to slowly unravel its secrets in a way that feels both really fresh and really engaging, such that I had a hard time putting this really big novel down. This is the first of a trilogy, so the book is in no way stand alone, but it does resolve the arc it starts in a way that doesn't feel like you were cheated out of getting a full story here. And the characters it introduces, particularly protagonist Neema and a few others, are excellent and fascinating to read about. There are some negatives - if you're looking for a potential court intrigue setup or for the conspiracy reveals to make a ton of logical sense, you're probably in the wrong place here - but overall I really enjoyed The Raven Scholar and am excited to try to read the sequel next year.






