SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: The Isles of Glass by Judith Tarr: https://t.co/VmhXf64kEz
— Josh (garik16) (@garik16) March 24, 2022
Short Review: 7.5 out of 10
1/3
Short Review (cont): A Historical Fantasy set during the 12th Century/Crusades, featuring a monk struggling with his fae nature as he is forced to leave his monastery for the first time to attempt to stop a war. Solid and well done and will appeal to more Christian audiences
— Josh (garik16) (@garik16) March 24, 2022
2/3
The Isle of Glass is the first book in Judith Tarr's "The Hound and the Falcon" historical fantasy trilogy. Tarr is a name I've known for a while - in part from her Tor.com column on horses in fiction and reality, and in part based upon her name popping up on lists of classic authors to check out, but I hadn't ever gotten a chance to try any of her fiction out before. So when I saw this trilogy praised on twitter, I looked it up and found this first book available via inter-library loan, and here we are.
And well, The Isle of Glass is a perfectly enjoyable historical fantasy novel set during the 12th century and the Crusades (or well in between them), featuring a Fae/Elf/Changeling devout monk, who is forced to confront what he is when he's sent to King Richard (yes that Richard) from his monastery in an attempt to stop a war. It's well done for what it is - its hero's self-hate and martyr complex are very understandable in light of the religious/personal conflicts the hero has over his very being, and the side characters are very enjoyable as they support/antagonize him - although what it is, to be honest, has limited appeal to me. But if you're more interested in fantasy set amongst middle ages/crusades-era Christianity, I suspect The Isle of Glass and its sequels will very much appeal to you.