Thursday, December 31, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Thorn by Intisar Khanani

 



Thorn was an originally self published YA Fantasy novel by Intisar Khanani, which was picked up by a major publisher and rereleased this year.  I've actually read one of Khanani's earlier fantasy self-published series (Sunbolt/Memories of Ash), which were both very enjoyable if highly and sometimes distractingly derivative of other works (My review of both stories are here and here).  So it's no surprise that Thorn is openly derivative - the story is in large part an adaptation of The Brothers Grimm's fairy tale "The Goose Girl" into a more fantasy-esque world, to go along with other additions to make this a full novel.  

And well, Thorn manages to portray a strong voiced main character and deals with some strong themes about class and justice in a monarchal fantasy world, which made often made it compelling and hard to put down.  These themes are grafted on as additions to the fantasy version of The Goose Girl story (featuring vengeful Sorceress) and the additions work incredibly well.  At the same time however, the book tries to stick to the story of The Goose Girl as its skeleton, and always comes back to that story even when it's significantly less interesting than the additions.  The result works overall as a novel, but couldn't help make me long for a version of this book less tied to the original Brothers Grimm story.  

TRIGGER WARNING:  Rape (never on page, but the after effects are seen) and Physical Abuse, rarely on page, form major parts of the plot.  They're handled well and are never superfluous, but be forewarned.  

Note:  I read this in audiobook form, and as such if I misspell any names or concepts, that's the reason why.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Wednesday, December 30, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Hollow Empire by Sam Hawke:

 



Hollow Empire is the sequel to last year's "City of Lies," a both fascinating and frustrating fantasy novel from Astonishing Award nominee Sam Hawke.  The book featured a brother and sister - Jovan and Kalina - in the intriguing the State of Sjona and its capital city of Silasta, a city of ideals, where people can seemingly do what they want and love who they want...but secretly was built on a system of oppression.  Jovan and Kalina were both heavily privileged - their family is both publicly high in status and secretly in charge with proofing the Chancellor of Sjona's food for poison - and as such a large portion of the book was them figuring out how much they really didn't know about the lives of many who lived in their City-State, and how to deal with the rebellion of those oppressed peoples who...may have actually been in the right.  Add in Court Intrigue, a Mystery Traitor or Two, and the hinting of real dangerous magic in this low fantasy setting, and you had a very well done and enjoyable first book, even if it did have a few problems that prevented it from being one of my favorites from last year.

Hollow Empire follows up on the story two years later, once again with the story split between Jovan and Kalina's points of view, and dealing now with the cleanup from the class conflict and rebellion from the first book, while the city's unknown enemy remains out there.  This poses some interesting thematic questions about handling the aftermath and repairing the damage of oppression, but overall the result is a book that is a bit less interesting in themes than its predecessor.  On the other hand, our two main characters have grown tremendously since the first book for the most part, and that's such a really enjoyable thing to see.  Add in some more court/political intrigue, magic, foreign powers, and potential romance, and Hollow Empire may not live up to its predecessor, but it's still a very solid book.  

More after the jump, but warning: Spoilers for City of Lies are inevitable.

Note: I read this mostly as an audiobook, and the two readers are again excellent...but they are NOT the same readers as the ones for City of Lies, which is a bit disorienting.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Tuesday, December 29, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Doors of Sleep by Tim Pratt

 

Full Disclosure:  This book was read as an e-ARC (Advance Reader Copy) obtained via Netgalley from the publisher in advance of the book's release on January 12, 2021 in exchange for a potential review.  I give my word that this did not affect my review in any way - if I felt conflicted in any way, I would simply have declined to review the book. 


Doors of Sleep is the latest book by author Tim Pratt, whose work I've previously enjoyed quite a bit (see his "The Axiom" trilogy or his most recent tie-in The Fractured Void).  Those novels were all fun space operas featuring fun casts of misfit characters having enjoyable relationships, quirks and smart interactions with dangerous enemies, and for the most part I really liked the results, even if none of the books were truly tremendous enough to fall into my "must read" category.  Doors of Sleep is the start of a new series which isn't quite space opera, so I was curious to see how it would read compared to those others.

And Doors of Sleep is very fun and entertaining, which reminds me of a number of other stories, from Marie Brennan's Memoirs of Lady Trent in writing style to well, Doctor Who, in that it features a man traveling through different worlds accompanied by occasionally changing companions and trying to do good on as many of those worlds as he can.  And yet it's not Doctor Who, in that our protagonist is not some mad genius but just a well meaning accidental traveler, who is far more human and thus breakable than that show's classic hero.  The result, aided by Pratt's solid entertaining writing, is a rather fun (although not comedic unlike his other works) and well done novel that ends on a satisfying point while promising more to come.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Monday, December 28, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Blazewrath Games by Amparo Ortiz

 




Blazewrath Games is a YA Fantasy novel that is also the debut of author Amparo Ortiz.  The novel features a plot that will feel very reminiscent of other novels in its alternate history fantasy setup:  take our world, add a second world of magicians that becomes known to the "regular" public years in the past, add in dragons who often bond with other humans with various magical abilities and physical forms, and finally have all these things come together with a World Cup of a sport involving all of it.  So yes, this one certainly will remind readers of some major elements from Harry Potter, because it certainly seems like the author set out at one point to do her own spin on that, except centered on a Puerto Rican girl (and featuring many other people of color) in a world filled with publicly-out LGTBQ people, and a fantasy sport that makes slightly more sense than Quidditch.

Which could be a pretty good starting point for a novel, but Blazewrath Games - though fun - has a lot of problems.  The book is clearly trying very hard to do a better job with its world in all the areas Harry Potter failed, and to deal with strong themes such as what it means to be Puerto Rican in the diaspora vs from the island itself, about self-confidence in the face of despair, and about the power in just being yourself....but it stumbles repeatedly, never quite fully exploring any of these themes in depth.  Add in a plot that suggests some interesting twists and turns and basically has none, a problematic sportswashing element that misleads the reader about the state of our own world, and well....I just wish this had faced another serious edit, as its fun core gets swamped by the other problems.  

Note: I read this half as an audiobook, and the audiobook reader is excellent.  So if you do want to read it, that format is worth your time.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Friday, December 25, 2020

Fantasy Novella Review: Over the Woodward Wall by A Deborah Baker

 


Over the Woodward Wall by A. Deborah Baker

Over the Woodward Wall is a middle-grade novella with an odd backstory.  The story first featured as an in-universe book in Seanan McGuire's stand alone adult novel "Middlegame," as a Wizard of Oz-like story written as a coded guide to teach the fictional author Baker's disciples alchemy.  McGuire wrote snippets of the story for Middlegame and decided (with the Publisher) to eventually actually write the full story as its own stand alone middle-grade novel (Baker is of course, another of McGuire's pseudonyms here). 

So it's not surprising that the story is a fun middle grade tale of two different children going on an adventure trying to get home from a strange fantasy world, one which really will remind readers of both The Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland quite a bit.  What is surprising is how incomplete the story is, with it just....ending and it begging for a sequel.  I can't imagine children reading this being satisfied as a result and can imagine them frustrated which just makes it weird, and while this is fun for adults, it won't be more than an interesting curiosity. 

More specifics after the jump.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Thursday, December 24, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Flytrap by Stephanie Ahn

 



Flytrap is the third book in Stephanie Ahn's "Harrietta Lee" urban fantasy series, which began with Deadline (Review Here) a few years ago and continued with last year's "Bloodbath" (Review Here).  This series is one of the rare self-published series that I've actually both tried and am now trying to keep up with, so I was excited when I realized this third book had been published during quarantine and that I'd missed it.  For those who haven't heard of the series, it features Harry Lee, masochistic (in the sexual sense, explicitly) lesbian and disgraced blood witch, as she navigates New York trying to deal with the mess of her life and the magical world.  It's a fairly explicit series - the first book features full BDSM play, the second pretty explicit (lesbian obv) sex with a demon - so it won't be for everyone, and it has some narrative issues that you might expect from self published work from a relatively new writer, but it's a lot of fun to read.  

Flytrap is more of the same, for better or worse.  It's still a very enjoyable and fun narrative with its masochistic lesbian blood witch heroine, and if you enjoyed the sex scenes in the last one, they are taken up a notch this time around.  The plot is actually tighter than book 2 as well, which helps things move a lot more smoothly, and the prose is really well done.  On the other hand, as the third installment in a series, the book feels weird, with old characters never showing up and new characters and traumas popping up that you'd think would've been mentioned before.  Hopefully the next book in the series feels more like part of a series than this one, but on its own, this is still very fun.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Wednesday, December 23, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Rebel Sisters by Tochi Onyebuchi

 



Rebel Sisters is Tochi Onyebuchi's follow up to his YA novel "War Girls" (see my review here) one of my favorite - and easily one of the most devastating - novels of last year.  War Girls was a novel essentially in the vein of RF Kuang's The Poppy War - in that it took a real world conflict, filled with horrible atrocities, and shifted it into a genre setting.  And well, moving the horrors of the Nigerian-Biafran Civil War into the future and adding giant mechas didn't make the story any less devastating, especially as it followed two sisters on opposite sides of the conflict.  And the story concluded in a satisfying if heartbreaking fashion, all the while making serious points using its historical background, that it never really made me think it needed a sequel, so when I found out it was getting one I was both frightened and excited.

And Rebel Sisters is....a hell of a sequel, although a much harder book to pin down than its predecessor.  It once again features past and present atrocities shifted into the future or at least referred to, although those atrocities are more from all over the world rather than specifically from its mainly Nigerian setting (the exiling of refugees and their physiological reaction to the threat of deportations, the adopting of such refugees by privileged white folk, and the genocide and erasure of the Uyghur people by China, etc.).  It combines these historical and present day horrors into a plot featuring characters who are forced to react to it all and try to find answers....but it stops well short of trying to suggest there are answers at all.  Indeed, one of the book's central arguments is left with an "answer" that is so ambiguous as to leave many readers thinking about it for days afterwards...and I'm not quite sure it how to feel about it.  

More specifics after the jump (Spoilers for War Girls are unmarked below, although I don't think they matter too much to your enjoyment of that book):

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Tuesday, December 22, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Persephone Station by Stina Leicht

 

Full Disclosure:  This book was read as an e-ARC (Advance Reader Copy) obtained via Netgalley from the publisher in advance of the book's release on January 5, 2021 in exchange for a potential review.  I give my word that this did not affect my review in any way - if I felt conflicted in any way, I would simply have declined to review the book.


Persephone Station is an SciFi novel by former Astounding Award nominee Stina Leicht, who was one of the first authors I wound up reading way back when I got back into the genre.  Her two flintlock epic fantasy novels, Cold Iron and Blackthorne, were in some ways really interesting in what they were trying to do with their multiple characters...yet at the same time often felt incomplete or missing sections of connective tissue needed for plot or character building.  And this was despite both of those books being 600 pages long.  But when this book popped up on NetGalley, I was curious to see whether that pattern would hold true here (especially since she'd worked on this instead of a sequel to Blackthorne).  

And I enjoyed Persephone Station a good bit, even if it very much shares some of the same problems as Blackthorne and Cold Iron.  It's a really interesting  multi-character Sci-Fi novel, featuring the intersection of sentient AIs, human mercenaries and criminals, a powerful human corporation, as well as pacifist aliens who just want to live in peace, with a lot of moving parts and a clear inspiration from The Magnificent Seven/Seven Samurai.  And it mostly comes all together in the end to a satisfying ending.  On the other hand, while our foremost leading character is excellent, the book has too many pieces to truly develop everyone satisfactorily, leaving other parts of itself feeling incomplete.  Still very much worth a read, even if it can't quite live up to its potential.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Monday, December 21, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik

 



A Deadly Education is the latest novel - and the start of a new trilogy - by award winning fantasy author Naomi Novik.  Novik has written two types of novels - her stand alone fairy tale subversions (Uprooted, Spinning Silver) or her alternate history fantasy Temeraire series (The Napoleonic Wars with Dragons!).  I really really enjoyed the latter - the whole Temeraire series was tremendous fun and I highly recommend it - but haven't quite loved the former, with Spinning Silver really not working at all for me.  So I was not sure what to expect from A Deadly Education, since it didn't really fit into either category.  

What I found was a book I really enjoyed, even if it had a few quirks that were kind of annoying.  The book's first person narrator is fantastic, and while the book has a tendency to infodump, her sarcastic tone and wit prevent the book from ever dragging.  Add in a very fun setting - a magic school in which everything is basically trying to kill all the students and a protagonist with the power but not the temperament to cause mass destruction - and some solid underlying themes and you have a book that is pretty damn good as the start of a new series.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Sword and Pen by Rachel Caine

 



Sword and Pen is the fifth and final book in the late Rachel Caine's "The Great Library" series of alternate history fantasy novels.  I've really enjoyed the series so far, which took the setup provided by its first book and used it to take a leap to another level for books 2-4, with book 4 (Smoke and Iron, reviewed here) switching up the book's format to tremendous effect.  But five book series are in my experience trickier than your classic trilogies, with the extra length making it hard for the series to come to a satisfactory conclusion, so I was a bit worried that Sword and Pen might not live up to its predecessors.  

And honestly, it doesn't - Sword and Pen concludes the story with tremendous drama and tension, with some really strong moments, but doesn't quite hit on all the emotional beats it's going for.  And while the conclusion is one that works in the end as a resolution, I didn't quite love it (and the book seeming to forget about two major antagonists doesn't help), making this perhaps my least favorite book in the series.  Don't get me wrong, this is still a solid novel, and as a resolution to the major plot threads it works - it just tries to do too much and can't quite measure up to what came before.

Spoilers for the first four books are inevitable, be forewarned.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Friday, December 18, 2020

Fantasy Novella Review: When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain by Nghi Vo

 

When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain by Nghi Vo 

When The Tiger Came Down the Mountain is author Nghi Vo's second novella this year, after The Empress of Salt and Fortune (Review Here).  I enjoyed that first novella, as a tale of an empress, cast aside by her husband, taking action into her own hands to take back everything from him, while also being a tale of love and companionship at the same time, with it all taking place in an East Asian-inspired setting (I think Vietnamese-inspired) .  I didn't love it as much as others did, but it was pretty well done and worth your time.  

Empress was told through a framing device to a cleric, Chih, and this second novella also features a similar framing device, although Chih themself is a more prominent character this time around.  The result is a F-F romantic story between a woman seeking to become a scholar and a tiger-woman she encounters on the way, with the story being told both by Chih and a trio of other Tigers who they encounter - in often very different ways.  The story within the story, and the different versions told by each party, combine to make this one a real winner that is pretty pretty great.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Thursday, December 17, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Tail of the Blue Bird by Nii Ayikwei Parkes

 


Tail of the Blue Bird is a short (just under 200 pages) novel by Nii Ayikwei Parkes.  It's arguable whether it really fits the category of Fantasy (its more usually listed as literary fiction, and whether anything fantastical happens is an open question).  The story takes place in what are essentially two different worlds in Ghana - a modern city world of Ghana, in which foreign knowledge is used and misused by corrupt officials and businessmen for their own gain and a more traditional rural world, in which people are not unaware of modern advancements, but still live as per tradition - hunting, medicine making....and believing in things like horrifying curses.

This is a short novel, featuring a young man who was educated abroad to be a forensic pathologist to help the Country uncover answers other than superstition only to run into people who don't actually want answers, is certainly interesting - and worth a read for audiences who are likely unfamiliar with the setting.  

TRIGGER WARNING:  Abuse of a girl and then a woman by her father, resulting in multiple miscarriages.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Wednesday, December 16, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Smoke and Iron by Rachel Caine

 



Smoke and Iron is the 4th and penultimate novel in Rachel Caine's "The Great Library" Alternate History Fantasy series.  I don't need to say any more here in these reviews how much I've loved these books, and book 3, Ash and Quill (Reviewed Here), was a new highlight....and ended on the most dramatic cliffhanger yet.  Our hero, Jess, and his friends are somehow in their greatest peril yet, and well: I could barely wait to pick up this fourth novel, to the point where I read the first 1/3 in audiobook and then couldn't stop myself from finishing the rest in ebook form over the weekend instead of waiting for the workweek to come.  Oops.  

So yeah, you shouldn't be surprised that this book is once again really strong, but what is surprising is how much it departs from the structure of the prior three books.  Caine used this new structure to give a greater picture of things as they go on, and the result is a more complete book that showcases more than usual the growth each of these characters has made over the course of the series.  So yeah, I'll be starting book 5 in audiobook this coming week, and we'll see if I can resist finishing it in print early.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Tuesday, December 15, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Architects of Memory by Karen Osborne

 



Architects of Memory is the debut novel of SF/F author Karen Osborne (who has previously written short fiction).  It's an idea-filled short science fiction novel featuring a universe in which human space is run by corporate entities, who each have their own versions of citizenship and who force those who wish to obtain it into forms of indenture.  It's a common theme/concept that I've seen a bunch in science fiction published recently (for examples, see Martha Wells' Murderbot or Kameron Hurley's The Light Brigades or Emma Newman's Planetside series) and Osborne adds to it a war with a seemingly unknowable alien species to create a book that was getting a little bit of buzz before release.

The result is a book with some interesting ideas, and some decent characters...but with a writing style that often left me confused as to what exactly was going on.  This isn't helped by how I read books - reading fast often means that I miss aspects of detail-oriented prose and while this isn't that, it's possible that some of my confusion was due to how terse the explanations really were.  It still mostly works, but the result, and the sheer amount of ideas that it's trying to deal with - about freedom/corporate ownership, about coexistence, about war and vengeance, etc. - kind of diminishes a lot of its effectiveness.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Monday, December 14, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Iron Heart by Nina Varela

 



Iron Heart is the second half of a duology by Nina Varela that began with last year's Crier's War (which I reviewed here).  The duology is a young adult fantasy (arguably scifi in some aspects as well) story with a F-F romance between its two protagonists at its core, as the two girls from different backgrounds/species struggle with an unjust (racist/speciesist/classist) world and what to do about it, in the face of those who would seek to take advantage of those forces to cement their own power.  I liked Crier's War's setup a good amount, and its two main characters worked, but the book's ending was a major disappointment, with it just ending at a seeming random point in the middle of things, which was entirely unsatisfying.  So I was hoping the 2nd half of the duology would bring things around instead to a better conclusion.

And well, Iron Heart is a solid conclusion, even as it feels very much like the 2nd half of a what should have been a single novel instead of a duology.  Our protagonists remain strong as they try and deal with their new desperate situations and their uncertainty over having feelings for one another, and the roles of the varying antagonists come more firmly into play here, leading to a conclusion that is generally pretty satisfying.  At the same time, some antagonists are dealt with more easily than one would have imagined, and one of the major plot mysteries just dies out.  There was probably enough material in this setting/plot for one and a half books or maybe a more full duology, but instead we got what is essentially 1 book split into two, and the result is enjoyable but not quite as good as it could be. 

Spoilers for Crier's War below are inevitable.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Wednesday, December 9, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Ash and Quill by Rachel Caine

 



Ash and Quill is the third book in Rachel Caine's five book "The Great Library" alternate world fantasy series, which began with Ink and Bone.  Set in an alternate history in which the Library of Alexandria not only survived, but amassed great power via its control over knowledge, which it controls via some magic as well as an iron fist, its a dark tale of a group of young adults/teens fighting for freedom and knowledge.  The first book left me thrilled with the setting but not with where the characters wound up, but the second book (Paper and Fire) made me come around, so I was excited to get back to the series as soon as possible.

And Ash and Quill is utterly tremendous, all the while being the darkest book yet.  The characters, from main protagonist Jess, to the rest of his friends and family, have grown tremendously over the course of the first two books and grow further still in strong well plotted ways, and the action moves forward tremendously with the plot as well.  And themes of power, of control, of symbolism, and freedom, to say nothing of the horrors of war and PTSD, are once again hammered here brilliantly.  It doesn't all quite work for me with the setting, but it almost does, and I can't wait in two weeks to start book 4 as I have planned.   

Spoilers for Books 1-2 are inevitable, so be warned.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Tuesday, December 8, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: How the Multiverse Got Its Revenge by K Eason

 



How the Multiverse Got Its Revenge is the second book in K Eason's Thorne Chronicles duology, a terribly titled* SF/fantasy duology featuring a young princess, her guards, her mentor in both politics and what is essentially magic, in a twisty plot featuring rival political factions around the universe all told in by a slightly-irreverent historian narrator.  I enjoyed the first book, How Rory Thorne Destroyed the Multiverse (Reviewed here), quite a bit - there was nothing essential about it, but it was a fun story, with an enjoyable heroine in Rory who used her intelligence, a magic gift to always hear the truth behind one's words, and her own magic-hacking skills to defeat a dictator, earn her freedom and change the universe.  So I was looking forward to a sequel especially in these rough times, just for a bit of fun.  

*As I noted in my review of the first book, this book uses the word "Multiverse" as a synonym for "Universe", for no particular reason, which is a bit annoying, and while this book is better titled than its predecessor as describing what happens sort-of, it's still not very descriptive.  

And this sequel is....odd.  The book's narration acts as if the novel is setup similar to the first, with Rory as its protagonist, but really the focus shifts to Rory's companions in two pairs: Jaed and Thorsdottir & Rupert and Grytt, dealing with an emerging universal crisis featuring a trio of alien races and a weapon that threatens everyone's existence.  The parts dealing with these two pairs are highly enjoyable and fun, even if they don't quite end the way I was hoping, and the expansion of the setting was always intriguing.  But the book doesn't do anything really with that expansion, or with Rory herself, and wraps an awful lot up at the end as if the author had a whole third book planned out but didn't have the opportunity or desire to actually write and publish it.  There's still a good amount of fun here, but it's surrounded by missed opportunities which make it also a disappointment.

Note: I read this, like its predecessor in audiobook format, so if I misspell any names below, my apologies.  That said, the reader is very good, so if you plan to read this, reading in audiobook is a solid choice.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Monday, December 7, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: The Scapegracers by Hannah Abigail Clarke

 




The Scapegracers is a young adult novel and a debut novel from author Hannah Abigail Clarke.  It's very much a YA novel about queer and female empowerment - and of course the magic of witches/a coven in the modern world.  This makes it essentially the third novel of this sort I've read this year* (and 2nd explicitly YA one), which is kind of unfair because while the Scapegracers hits many of the same themes of those novels, it is also very different in its direction.  

*Sarah Gailey's When We Were Magic and Alix E Harrow's The Once and Future Witches are the two books that pop up in my head*

And it's a direction that I liked a lot - this is absolutely not a subtle novel about its themes, with one major character basically explaining them out loud to the protagonist, but it weaves them in and deals with them in interesting ways.  And by themes here, I mean mainly the power of young women - young queer women particularly - in a world that tries relentlessly to keep them all down.  Add in a really strong and enjoyable protagonist and some very solid side characters, and you have a very strong book, even if it relies a little too much on the characters' being deliberately obtuse about certain things that will be obvious to the reader immediately.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Friday, December 4, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Jade War by Fonda Lee

 





Jade War is the second book in Fonda Lee's "The Green Bone Saga", after 2018's "Jade City".  These books are part of a trilogy with an easy and very appealing hook: it's The Godfather meets Wuxia/Kung Fu/Magical Ninjas/whatever you want to call it, and the first book in the trilogy really lived up to that marketing hook.  And yet for some reason, while the book's craft was undeniable, and the plot was never boring, I just never felt the drive to continue with the book's sequel, even taking out the book once from the library for a period of a month and a half before putting it back unread, because I never had time to reread Jade City.  But Jade War was nominated for the Ignyte Award for Best Novel, so I found time to give it one more shot.  

And well Jade War is more of the same.  If you wanted an Asian or Hong Kong inspired fantasy take on the Godfather and liked how that played out in Jade City?  You'll like that here, especially as it moves to a larger scale (ala Godfather 2), expanding its plot beyond its central Island of Kekon into neighboring nations, with major impacts.  On the other hand, for me, I just came away from it all a little cold, never bored exactly, but never really inspired to keep reading - and one of the protagonist's actions left me with a serious bad taste.  I may or may not be continuing into book 3 when it comes out next year, but if I do, I won't be bothering with a reread of this one first, it hasn't quite earned the time.

Note: Spoilers for Jade City are inevitable below.  You are forewarned.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Thursday, December 3, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: We Hunt the Flame by Hafsah Faizal

 




We Hunt the Flame is a YA Fantasy novel from Hafsah Faizal, featuring an Arabia/Muslim-inspired setting.  I missed the novel at first, but it won the Ignyte Award in October for best YA novel in 2019 over a couple novels I'd really loved.  So I was definitely interested in checking it out, and since it was a pretty big book sales wise, it was no surprise that all my libraries and Hoopla had a copy.  So I read it over a week in both audiobook* and print form, so that I could finish it in a single work week.

And well, I enjoyed We Hunt the Flame a good bit, as a very enjoyable piece of YA Fantasy with its non-Western based setting, a pair of very enjoyable protagonists, and a plot that might be more than a bit predictable, but is executed really well overall.  On the other hand, the novel isn't just predictable but relies upon a plot formula that has been done to death in recent years, and while it works well enough, it's also not quite strong enough to stand out significantly from the pack.  In short, I enjoyed this, and am happy to have read it, and definitely await the sequel, but I just couldn't love it as much as others seem to have done.  

*Usual Disclaimer about spelling and reading this in audiobook applies to this review.  Of note, the audiobook features two very different readers for each of its characters' points of view, and it's a bit jarring, even if the two are done well individually.*

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Wednesday, December 2, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: The Blazing Star by Imani Josey

 




The Blazing Star is the first in a YA Fantasy series by author Imani Josey, which came out back in 2017.  Its sequel is coming out in December, although from a small press (or self published?) such that you can only pre-order it from the author's website.  So yeah, it's not the type of book I would usually find out about or be able to obtain from the library (interlibrary loan had a few copies), but when the author's tweets about her stunning covers hit my twitter feed, well I was interested.  

And well, The Blazing Star is a good start to a series, if one that very much feels like just a start.  This is a book about a trio of black teens from Atlanta who go back in time to ancient Egypt, where they get involved in a conflict of magic and power.  It's an enjoyable setting, with enjoyable characters, particularly our main protagonist, a fraternal twin who always feels overshadowed by her beloved sister, even if the plot is in many ways kind of predictable.  But again, it very much does not stand on its own, and with it being such a short book (under 300 pages paperback), it's not as satisfying as I would have hoped.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Tuesday, December 1, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Triangulum by Masande Ntshanga

 




Triangulum is the second novel (and first SF/F novel) by South African author Masande Ntshanga.  The book is nominated for this year's Nommo Awards, which attempt to celebrate the Best Speculative Fiction published by African authors.  It's not a long novel, but it's one that doesn't reward quick reading, drawing heavily upon the events of South African past in order to tell a story about both the present and the future.*  

*Note: I said this in another review recently but it definitely applies more here, and I'll make note of this again below: this book draws heavily upon the events of Apartheid South Africa and the events that have taken place since then for the context of its story, and as such as a White (Jewish) American, I lack knowledge about the context of the setting to a good extent.  As such, this book isn't written FOR me, and I very much am likely to have missed significant parts of what's going on in the background and how it affects the book's themes.   

And well, Triangulum is a fascinating novel that tries to do many different things at once, with these things not often obviously tied together.  The story features three timelines featuring the same un-named protagonist, from a document supposedly released (through the framing device) in 2043.  It's a coming of age story, a story of alien interactions, and also a story of how the cycles of oppression, slavery, and destruction have never ended - a story contrasting cruel treatment and control of others with that of love, and more.  Without the context of its intended audience, I'm not quite sure it fully works...but it's still well worth your time.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Monday, November 30, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Paper and Fire by Rachel Caine

 



Paper and Fire is the second book in Rachel Caine's "Great Library" series, following Ink and Bone (reviewed here).  The Great Library puts a different spin (for me at least) of a classical SF/F trope - the all powerful library who preserves knowledge for mankind....except here, the Library (of Alexandria in this alternate Earth) is a fascist controlling entity, not a real force for good.  I enjoyed the first book's setting and character work, but it's ending was a bit brutal, even for me, and I was a bit hesitant to continue on given that.  Still, since one of my favorite authors was recommending it, I opted to give it one more book in the series a try before I gave up.

And I'm rather glad I did, because Paper and Fire mostly avoids the tropes and character-usage that I feared after book 1, and continues a story that is hard not to get completely caught up in.  Most of the lead characters remain fascinating to read about and the story continues to drop hints about things going in the background that make it all so hard not to keep reading, so that we can finally see how it all pays off.  And again, we deal with themes about the power of knowledge, the value of knowledge vs that of a life, and more.  It's still not a perfect book with some clear issues, but it's better and I'll be continuing on to book 3 soon enough.

Note 1:  I read this as an audiobook, and the reader is very good, but if as a result I misspell some names/places below that's why.

Note 2:  Again the plot summary on Amazon is bad, so don't read it as it spoils events that occur in the last 10% of the book.  If you liked the first book, you'll like this.  

Note 3:  SPOILERS for book 1 are unhidden below, as they are unavoidable.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Friday, November 27, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Ink and Bone by Rachel Caine



Ink and Bone is the first book in Rachel Caine's "Great Library" series of alternate history SF/ novels, the fifth and final book of which came out in 2019.  Caine was* an author I've seen fairly respected on twitter and I've always wanted at some point to try her out, but well she has a substantial back catalog so it was hard to figure out where to begin.  But when Kate Elliott and Zoraida Córdova began a bimonthly reread of this series on the Tor.com blog, well that made my choice of starting point fairly obvious, and I wanted to catch up to them if I could.  Fortunately, the Hoopla eLibrary has the whole thing in audiobook, so it was easy to pick up.

*Caine, real name Roxanne Conrad, passed away from cancer between the time I finished the last audiobook in this series and this one.  I only wish I'd gotten to her work before this.  

And well, Ink and Bone is a very interesting start to a series, one in which I'm not sure is for me.  Like many SF/F series, it's a book centered in large part around a powerful Library - in this case an alternate Library of Alexandria that survived and expanded throughout the world, using magic to control the flow of books.  But unlike most of those series I've read, the Library is not a force for good - it's essentially a Fascist international power that uses its absolute control of the flow of information for its own ends, and the world that this takes place in is a dark dark place as a result.  Into this world comes our 16/17 year old protagonist and a group of friends who are supposedly training to become part of the Library...only to run into the realities of this world.  It's well done mostly, but the darkness and where Caine takes it goes in certain directions I don't particularly love...but that may be more of a matter of personal taste.

Note:  The Book Summary on Amazon/Other-Booksellers, which I presume is also on the book's back cover, is awful and spoils an even that occurs in the last two 10% of the book.  It's not really a surprise when it happens, but you're still better off avoiding that book summary if you can.  

Note2:  I read this as an audiobook, and I would recommend it in that format: the reader is very good, with solid different voices for basically every character, and really adds to the experience.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Thursday, November 26, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Miss Meteor by Tehlor Kay Mejia and Anna-Marie McLemore

 


Miss Meteor is a short YA novel co-written by authors Tehlor Kay Mejia (We Set the Dark on Fire) and Anna-Marie McLemore (Blanca & Roja).  It's more of a YA queer teenage rom-com than a fantasy novel - the fantasy element here is one of the main characters literally comes from the stars but that's more a metaphorical plot device than anything, so if you're looking for a clear genre work, you're not going to find it here.  This is the tale of two 16 year old girls who don't quite fit in - two brown hispanic girls, one pansexual tomboy and one short and stocky who talks to cacti for fun, and neither in any sense popular.

And this is a tale that is just incredible sweet and charming and had me smiling by its end, in sheer joy at how things turn out.  Our two protagonists feel both totally real and easy to root for, as they strive just one time to make something for themselves, and the romances they get involved in are just so so sweet, even if it takes them both a long time to figure it out.  The side characters are well done as are the antagonists, and while the general description totally could come out of a classical teenage rom-com, it all takes place instead in a world filled with people who classically didn't get to be in those Hollywood works - the Hispanic/non-white-skinned girls, the poor communities in small towns, and those who aren't cis or straight.  The result is a YA book that will absolutely be a darling to a populace who badly needs books like this, and I'd recommend it for others as well.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Wednesday, November 25, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Anthology Review: A Universe of Wishes, edited by Dhonielle Clayton

 

Full Disclosure:  This book was read as an e-ARC (Advance Reader Copy) obtained via Netgalley from the publisher in advance of the book's release on December 8, 2020 in exchange for a potential review.  I give my word that this did not affect my review in any way - if I felt conflicted in any way, I would simply have declined to review the book.

A Universe of Wishes is an anthology from "We Need Diverse Books", an organization that is exactly what it says on the tin, featuring a variety of short stories from prominent "diverse" (usually meaning non White Male here) authors in SciFi/Fantasy writing today and edited by author Dhonielle Clayton.  I've enjoyed a few of the authors listed on its manifest - Tochi Onyebuchi, Mark Oshiro, Zoraida Córdova - among others, so I was excited to give this one a try when I saw it pop up on NetGalley.  

The result is however, even more uneven than I'm used to from short fiction anthologies, with some pretty great stories spread out alongside some pretty big whiffs.  Some of the whiffs mind you are because at least two of the stories take place in their authors' preexisting worlds (only one of which I've read), and thus don't feel complete outside the context of those worlds.  The anthology also doesn't, oddly to my view, provide an explanation for the background of each author to demonstrate to the reader where their voice comes from (and what makes it "diverse,"), leaving me a bit confused about a few of the authors who were selected for this collection.*  Still there's enough good stuff here from really great writers to be worth your time, especially for YA-age readers, even if it's not my favorite anthology of the year.

*It is usually not an author's obligation to explain their background to the reader - it's their private business whether they may in fact be mixed race or queer despite their appearances on the surface for example, and questions to them about these things are kind of icky.  But when the anthology is based upon voices being from not the dominant group - a diverse group - it's weird to me when there's not even an attempt at this, especially given at least a few of the authors included seem to be white women, who I don't count myself as "diverse" in the space of genre anymore.*  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Tuesday, November 24, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: King of the Rising by Kacen Callender

 


Full Disclosure:  This book was read as an e-ARC (Advance Reader Copy) obtained via Netgalley from the publisher in advance of the book's release on December 1, 2020 in exchange for a potential review.  I give my word that this did not affect my review in any way - if I felt conflicted in any way, I would simply have declined to review the book.


King of the Rising is the second book in Kacen Callender's "Islands of Blood and Storm" duology, which began with last year's "Queen of the Conquered.  Queen of the Conquered was my pick for best SF/F book of 2019 (My review here) and it recently picked up the World Fantasy Award for Best Novel.  It was a tremendously (brutal to read) novel about a black woman in an enslaved/colonized group of islands (inspired by Callender's home of the US Virgin Islands) who uses her magic (mind controlling) and wits not to free her people, but to obtain power and vengeance instead, no matter the cost.  Not to spoil anything before the jump, but it concluded with an absolutely devastating ending that made me both excited and terrified to see what Callender would do with a sequel that switched protagonists from someone so morally gray (to be generous) to someone actually good.  

And King of the Rising delivers, with a continuation of the story that is just as tremendously powerful, but in a very different way.  The story shift's focus to the perspective of Løren, the young man whose approval the last book's protag Sigourney tried to obtain...even as she held his reins as her slave.  Løren is a very different protagonist in that he's somehow an idealist - having experienced the pains of slavery and seen all its horrors, he's determined that the result of their revolution will be a better world not constrained by the ruling attitudes of the Fjern slave masters...but as with the last book, this is not a series about the triumph of the good, and things do not go easily for him despite his good intentions.  Add in a well done setting that shows us the perspectives of the various enslaved and formerly enslaved people on the Islands, and you wind up with another devastating novel, even if it has a few more flaws than its predecessor.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Monday, November 23, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue by V.E. Schwab

 



The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue marks the fifth book I've read by author V.E. Schwab, an author whose work I've had conflicted feelings about.  Schwab's prose has always worked really well for me, making it easy for me to devour her books with ease and with speed - which is not something I can say for every writer, even writers I enjoy.  On the other hand, the final products of that prose haven't always actually worked for me as well as others, with me pretty much hating the final book of her Darker Shade of Magic trilogy (A Conjuring of Light) and not really caring enough about her This Savage Song to go on to its sequel, even if I liked the earlier books/parts of those volumes.  Still, it had been over 2 years since I read one of her books - longer than I've been writing on this blog in fact - and so with this latest novel getting good press, I couldn't help but pick it up. 

And The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue is generally pretty good and enjoyable - a lovely story of life and love that I devoured once again fairly quickly.  It takes a premises I've read at least once if not twice before - the idea of a woman who is immediately forgotten by everyone the moment she leaves their sight  (see for example - the Sudden Appearance of Hope) - and makes it into a cohesive story about loneliness and love that kept me enthralled, with two really damn strong lead characters.  There are, like the other Schwab books I've read, a number of annoying quirks in the way, which mar it a little, but only a little, so I can actually recommend this one to others to read as something I've liked.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Friday, November 20, 2020

Horror/Fantasy Novella Review: The Route of Ice and Salt by José Luis Zárate (translated by David Bowles)

 

Full Disclosure:  This book was read as an e-ARC (Advance Reader Copy) obtained via Netgalley from the publisher in advance of the book's release on January 19, 2021 in exchange for a potential review.  I give my word that this did not affect my review in any way - if I felt conflicted in any way, I would simply have declined to review the book.


The Route of Ice and Salt by José Luis Zárate (translated by David Bowles)

The Route of Ice and Salt is a novella originally published in 1998 in Mexico by a small press trying to break into the local Science Fiction and Fantasy market with Mexican authors.  The novella was an adaptation of a small part of Bram Stoker's Dracula, namely the shipment of Dracula to England on the doomed ship Demeter, with the story being told from the point of view of its ill fated captain, now reimagined as a gay man in the homophobic world of 1897.  The novella apparently became a cult hit in Mexico (even though its publisher failed) and was translated into French at one point, but only now is being translated into English for English-speaking audiences.

It's an impressive work, especially when given the context in which it was produced, in presenting a gay man in a homophobic time, confronted with horror and finding it in himself to proclaim his own value at the end in the face of that horror.  I should add that this edition of the work comes backed with not one but three explanations of this context - a foreword by Silvia Moreno-Garcia explaining the context of its publication, a new foreword by the author as to why he would write a story about a Vampire and monsters, and an afterword by Poppy Z Brite on the literary connections between vampires and homosexuality and how that history applies to the novella.  So it's kind of hard to miss what this novella is doing in this package given all that comes with it, but fortunately, what it's doing is fairly well done.
Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Thursday, November 19, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Empire of Wild by Cherie Dimaline

 




Empire of Wild is the second novel* from Cherie Dimaline, a Canadian writer from the Métis community.  Her first novel, The Marrow Thieves, was a really strong (I reviewed it here) post apocalyptic YA novel in which the Native community was once again hunted for something the rest of the world didn't have (dreams).  So I was really interested to see Dimaline's first book for "adult" audiences and so here we are.

*Confusingly, the book's marketing lists this as her "American Debut," despite the fact that her first book was published in the far away land of Canada and was highly acclaimed in both countries.*

And Empire of Wild is a solid novel....but I kind of expected more from it after The Marrow Thieves?  It's a story of a woman in the Métis community trying to get back her husband from a White Christian preaching group run by a man who might be a mythological Métis monster, who has aims on using his preaching business to enable the continued appropriation of Métis/Native resources.  And it works, with believable characters and an interesting plotline from beginning to conclusion, but it honestly does less than I expected after her first book.  I don't know, this might be an expectations problem more than anything and let me try to better explain after the jump.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Wednesday, November 18, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Each of Us a Desert by Mark Oshiro

 




Each of Us a Desert is a YA Fantasy novel by author Mark Oshiro and is their second novel.  I missed their first novel (Anger is a Gift) but from twitter they've been on my radar for quite a while, and so I put this book on hold a while back.  Naturally it came in when I had a billion other books to get to, and I was tempted to send it back and put it back on hold for later.  

I'm really glad I resisted that temptation, because Each of Us a Desert is....something, something really damn impressive.  It's a tale of a young woman in a post-apocalyptic world, who has a magical gift that has bound her seemingly to only one destiny...who travels the world in search of something else, and finds what she could never have expected.  It's a tale of human ugliness at times, of how we justify evil behavior and try to make excuses for it, but it's also one of love and finding oneself, and of determining a better way forward.  

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Tuesday, November 17, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: A Song of Wraiths and Ruin by Roseanne A. Brown

 




A Song of Wraiths and Ruin is a book that I had on hold in various forms for a while - it was one of a trio of books decently hyped up books by women of color that came out around the same date in June, and was the only one of the trio that I couldn't quickly get my hands on.  It's author Roseanne A. Brown's debut novel, and a young adult fantasy tale inspire by West-African folktales, which naturally piqued my interest.  So I had this on hold from my physical library via inter-library loan and via audiobook vis the NYPL, and naturally it came in through both of those ways simultaneously.  

And I really enjoyed A Song of Wraiths and Ruin and definitely look forward to its sequel (this is apparently the first half of a duology).  The story features what is a pretty typical young adult framework: two protagonists, one from a place of privilege and one not, of opposite genders, meet each other, fall in love and have their views changed as things go to hell.  And yet, the book never takes the easy way out with that framework, and builds its characters in interestingly different directions all the way to a point which provides both a satisfying ending and a tantalizing cliffhanger at the same time.  

Note:  I read this as an audiobook, and this is yet another book that decides to use two audio-narrators: a male reader for the male protag and a female reader for the female protag.  Both readers are very solid, but their voices for their characters don't really come close to one another, which is a bit annoying.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Monday, November 16, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Sword in the Stars by A. R. Capetta and Cory McCarthy

 




Sword in the Stars is the sequel to A.R. Capetta and Cory McCarty's "Once and Future" - and the conclusion of this duology, which features a genderflipped queer scifi take on the King Arthur Mythos.  I really enjoyed the first novel - it wasn't truly a great novel, but it was a lot of fun with how self aware it was, with takes on Arthur (Ari, a lesbian woman of color fighting against an galaxy-spanning evil corporation) and Merlin (a gay man who ages backwards and is now a young man) that felt somehow fresh despite the old mythos used, and a plot that mostly worked from beginning to end.  I say mostly, because the book sort of felt like it threw a cliffhanger together out of nowhere that didn't really work, which annoyed me.  

But the cliffhanger leads into this book, Sword in the Stars, which concludes this series, and it's everything again I enjoyed about the first book, only with a shift into the classical Arthur timeline.  And yet, it stays self-aware, deals with themes like whitewashing and straight-washing the past, and above all remains really damn fun, with strong characters and plotting that would frequently make me smile.  Again, nothing about this is really that strong to make me consider this some kind of must-read, but it's still incredibly enjoyable and well worth any young adult reader's time - or even adult looking for some fun.  

Spoilers for Once & Future are inevitable below:

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Thursday, November 12, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Lost Gods by Micah Yongo


Lost Gods is the first in an epic fantasy series by Micah Yongo. It was a book I'd wanted to read for a long time after I saw a couple of people on twitter praise it except for some odd reason, my libraries never had a copy despite it coming from a major publisher. Oddly enough, I wound up getting an advance copy of this book's sequel (which I didn't realize was a sequel due to how the book was marketed) Pale Kings a while back and reviewed it without having read this book.  And I actually enjoyed Pale Kings, although I couldn't help but wonder if I might've gone as far as loved it if I'd had the background from reading book 1.  

And Lost Gods apparently turned up at the NYPL, so I took it out, and what I found was...an interesting fantasy novel that just didn't quite fascinate me as much as I'd hoped.  There was a solid world setup here with a very solid main plot, but separate side plots that popped up from time to time really never felt like more than a distraction, and were rather hard to care about.  I vaguely recall the second book doing better in this regard, and I do feel the urge to reread the second book now, so it's still a solid series starter by any means, and I really do hope the trilogy is completed at some point in the future.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Wednesday, November 11, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: The Fires of Vengeance by Evan Winter

 

Disclaimer:  This review is based upon an e-ARC provided by the publisher in exchange for a review.  I give my word that my reactions and review below are not affected by this and that this review is entirely fair and unbiased.  If I felt unable to review this book without bias, I would not have reviewed it.


The Fires of Vengeance is the second book in Evan Winter's "The Burning" epic fantasy series, which began with The Rage of Dragons.  That first book, which I believe was originally self published before being picked up by Orbit, was a hell of a start to a brutal new epic fantasy series (Review Here) inspired by Winter's Xhosa heritage and which dealt with issues of class, race, revenge, and colonization.  I compared the first book in that review to the anime Berserk because well: you had a revenge driven protagonist willing to go to unthinkable lengths to get stronger and achieve his goals in a world that is absolutely arrayed against him.  It ended in brutal form, and I was absolutely thrilled to get an early copy to read the sequel.  

And well, The Fires of Vengeance is an impressive follow-up, in pretty much all the ways you would imagine.  Our protagonist Tau remains a compelling determinator as he tries to wreak his vengeance in a world that seemingly wants more and more of him, and the series' side characters, both new and old, get some strong development as well to build this world up.  And we continue to deal with serious themes all the while.  Combine it all with some impressive writing that uses different points of view in some rather clever ways, and well, this is another winner.  

Note:  If you couldn't tell from the first book, this is an absolutely brutal book, bordering on grimdark.  If you enjoyed the first one and were able to deal with that, there's little here that will change your mind, although I guess I should add a Trigger Warning for SUICIDE.  

Spoilers for book 1 are inevitable to follow:

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Tuesday, November 10, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Medusa in the Graveyard by Emily Devenport



Medusa in the Graveyard is the sequel to 2018's Medusa Uploaded, a scifi novel which I reviewed here.  Medusa Uploaded - which I read as an audiobook - was an.....interesting book to say the least: in short, it was an utter mess, jumping back and forth in time for seemingly no reason, with characters acting in utterly unrealistic ways, and a plot that just got more and more crazy as our crazy and borderline psychopathic heroine learned more about her home, a generation ship (for example: our protagonist got thrown out an airlock at least five times).  But here's the thing: while it was an utter mess, it was an utterly fun mess, one where I really couldn't wait to see what our protagonist would do next. 

Medusa in the Graveyard is a similar book in many ways - it's again an utter mess, the characters act and talk (oh especially talk) in utterly insane ways, our protagonist is again kind of nuts. - but it loses a lot of the fun, honestly.  The book separates our main protagonist from her best ally - Medusa, the deadly tentacled AI machine - and expands the universe, but rarely gives the protagonist a chance to make any decisions on her own to change the outcomes, instead putting her on a journey through crazy new places where she is pinballed around in other beings' agendas.  Those beings are kind of interesting, but not nearly as interesting as our protagonist used to be, and removing her agency in favor of her melodrama is a losing trade, and makes this one not nearly as fun as its predecessor.

Note: I read this as an audiobook, so if I misspell any terms or names below, I apologize.  The audiobook reader is very good though at accentuating the bonkersness. 


Read more »
Posted by at No comments:

Monday, November 9, 2020

SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: The Burning God by R.F. Kuang

 



The Burning God is the third and final book in R.F. Kuang's "Poppy War" trilogy, which began with The Poppy War in 2018 (which I reviewed here) and continued in last year's The Dragon Republic (reviewed here).  The trilogy has been one of the most remarkable things I've read in the past few years - a brutal fantasy tale based heavily upon the events in China in the early 20th century, beginning with the Sino-Japanese Wars and continuing with events relating to China's colonization by forces of the West.  And I do mean brutal - this story is absolutely not afraid to go deep into fantasy versions of historical atrocities and then some, although it has never been gratuitous and always for creating a fascinating dark story of a girl from nothing (and others) driven to madness and destruction. 

Kuang has said in interviews that the trilogy's protagonist Fang Runin is a fantasy take on Mao, and as such, The Burning God takes the story in that direction....sort of.  It's an absolutely tremendous trilogy-ender, even if it didn't quite fully work in the middle third, with the story taking on serious themes of occupation and colonization, the brutal costs of war and the impossibility of rebuilding, and what is left for a person in the world after all the horrible acts they may have committed.  And of course, the story tackles the cycles of love and hate, with its two trios of characters finally getting their resolutions.  It's an incredible work, one in which people could probably write essays, but well, I'm just doing this review.  Let's give it a shot.

Note: This review is based upon an ARC that I won off a Goodreads giveaway, so it's possible that there were some minor alterations to the text in the final version.  Nothing I can do about that, and it's unlikely to affect my review, but fair warning.    

TRIGGER WARNING: Mass Death, Graves, Executions, and more atrocities are committed off and sometimes on page here, although any rape that is mentioned is off page and nowhere near as prevalent as in prior volumes.  But if you've gotten through the first two books with their far harsher content, you'll be okay here.

Spoilers for the first two books follow.

Read more »
Posted by at No comments:
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)