SciFi/Fantasy Book Review: Home is Not a Country by Safia Elhillo: https://t.co/tqmDrGdrpi
— Josh (garik16) (@garik16) July 1, 2021
Short Review; 9 out of 10
1/3
Short Review (cont): A tale of Magical Realism told entirely through pieces of poetry, as an immigrant muslim girl deals with prejudice, a tough life, and dreams of the girl she could have been if her mother had chosen a different name for her. Really good.
— Josh (garik16) (@garik16) July 1, 2021
2/3
Home is Not a Country is a YA book by poet Safia Elhillo. I use the word "book" there instead of novel, because the book is arguably hard to classify: it's a ~210 page story (in hardcover) told entirely in 1-4 page poems, from beginning to end. Which again is not to say that this a collection of independent poetry, but instead a complete story told in verse from beginning to end. And that's tricky for me to evaluate as honestly, I'm not really the most appreciative reader of poetry, with me usually getting annoyed at parts of book in verse, but I'd heard enough hype that I wanted to give this a try.
And I'm glad I did, because Home is Not a Country makes the poetry work really well. Oddly - and again this could just be my own personal inability to really get written poetry - none of the individual poems, with their line stops and varying lengths, really individually worked for me that much....but when combined together, this method of storytelling works tremendously well. As does the story, featuring a girl from an unidentified Middle Eastern/North-African country around 9/11 feeling uncomfortable in America and always wondering if she someone else - someone like the girl whose name her mom almost gave her. It's a really strong YA story about wishing for what one doesn't have instead do appreciating what little one does, even if what one does have comes with a lot of pain and difficulty fitting in in a country that isn't particularly welcoming to outsiders.